Learn How. Discover Why. Build Better. - Christopher Schwarz


Premium Dovetail Saws
Copyright 2008. Originally appeared in the Fine Tool Journal

  3 of 5

Wenzloff & Sons Kenyon-style Dovetail Saw

The Wenzloff & Sons “John Kenyon” dovetail saw is an 18th-century delight.  It’s like buying a new Kenyon saw from Christopher Gabriel himself in England back in the golden age of furniture.

The handle is shapely.  It’s thinner than the Lie-Nielsen at 13/16”, and the swelling in the grip is smaller, as are the handle’s hardlines.  The tote is made using a beautiful pale beech, which is a bit shocking at first because saw snobs (like me) expect beech saws to have dark brown or grimy totes.  And the wood is chosen with great care.  All of the beech Wenzloff handles I’ve seen use nice quartersawn stock that’s flecked with beautiful rays.  Also nice is the handle’s minimal finish – it’s smooth, but not slick.

But while the tote delights the eye, it pinches my palm a bit.  The horns at the top and bottom of the handle are beautiful, but I think they are too close together.  My hand feels a bit caged in by the horns.  If you have small hands, this might just be the saw you’ve been looking for.  If you have oversized mitts, you’ll want to try something else.

The Gramercy and Wenzloff saws have a traditional brass back
that is folded over the blade. The Lie-Nielsen (at right)
has a brass back that is slotted for the blade.

The next key feature of the saw is the brass back.  While the Lie-Nielsen’s brass back is one thick chunk of metal that is slotted for the blade, the Wenzloff’s saw has a brass back that is folded over the blade.  The folded back is a more traditional look, which is critical to the men and women who re-enact the story of our nation at living history museums.  But does the folded back improve the way this tool cuts dovetails?  Not in my experience.

The Wenzloff’s blade is .019” thick, the same as the Lie-Nielsen, and the Wenzloff has 16 points per inch that are filed rip.  As a result, the cutting characteristics of the Wenzloff and the stock 15 ppi Lie-Nielsen are similar.  Both of these saws track a line easily.  The Wenzloff saw cuts at about the same speed as the standard Lie-Nielsen (though the Lie-Nielsen progressive-pitch version has the land speed record).

One unique quality of the $130 Wenzloff saw is that it is the only one of the three to have a nice branded sawnut.  The Lie-Nielsen stamps its information on the brass back; the Tools for Working Wood saw has a sweet, crisp etch on its blade.

  3 of 5
   
   
 

For best viewing experience use Microsoft Internet Explorer.
Copyright © 1995-2008 wkFineTools.com and Wiktor Kuc.  All Rights Reserved.
Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners.